Federal Judge Dismisses Newsmax's Antitrust 'Shotgun Pleading' Complaint Against Fox News

Vandana Singh

September 07, 2025

Newsmax Inc. (NYSE:NMAX) on Wednesday filed a major federal antitrust lawsuit against Fox Corporation’s (NASDAQ:FOX) (NASDAQ:FOXA) and Fox News Network in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida.

On Friday, a federal judge dismissed Newsmax's antitrust lawsuit against Fox News just a day after it was filed. Newsmax filed a five-count complaint alleging violations.

The second, third, fourth, and fifth counts in the complaint, however, incorporate all preceding allegations, thus rendering the complaint an impermissible "shotgun pleading.

Also Read: 12 Stocks For 2025 NFL Season With $30 Billion Expected To Be Bet, $8 Million Super Bowl LX Ads

The suit accused Fox of engaging in an extensive and unlawful campaign to block competition in the market for right-leaning pay television news, including Newsmax.

Newsmax’s action sought damages. Under federal law, any damages awarded in this case will be trebled – meaning Fox could face significant financial liability if Newsmax prevailed.

The complaint alleged that Fox has abused its dominance in the right-leaning pay TV news market for years by coercing distributors into unfair carriage agreements designed to exclude or marginalize competitors like Newsmax.

Fox News, described in the complaint as a “must-have” channel for distributors, leverages its market power to impose restrictions that harm consumers, stifle competition, and drive up costs across the pay TV ecosystem.

Among the exclusionary tactics detailed in the complaint:

Fox conditions access to Fox News on agreements by distributors not to carry or to restrict competing right-leaning news channels.
If distributors carry Newsmax, Fox forces them to also carry low-demand channels like Fox Business or Fox Sports 2 in their most widely viewed tiers – triggering potentially tens of millions in extra fees.
These clauses penalize distributors for placing Newsmax in basic packages by requiring simultaneous promotion of Fox’s less popular channels.
Fox has allegedly pressured its guests not to appear on Newsmax, as well as run online smear campaigns and hired private investigators targeting Newsmax executives to damage the Company’s credibility.

The complaint asserted that Fox has deliberately blocked Newsmax’s growth in critical distribution platforms such as Hulu, Sling, Fubo, and other major platforms.

"Failure to comply with this Order may result in dismissal of the case without further notice," the judge wrote in the order on Friday.

The dismissal order notes that Newsmax may file an amended complaint by September 11, 2025. The amended complaint must not contain any successive counts that incorporate all prior allegations.

Price Action: NMAX stock closed at $13.31, and FOX stock closed at $55.97 on Friday.

Read Next:

As Waymo Begins Airport Testing Operations In San Jose, This User Compared The Fare Of Regular Uber Rides Vs Tesla Robotaxi

Image: Shutterstock/PJ McDonnell

Recommended

When Alabama Wins, This Nasdaq Brand Wins Too - Ad

Is This Elon's Worst Nightmare? - Ad

Could You Use Some Instant Cash Upfront? - Ad

Popular

Stock Of The Day: Breakdown In Archer Aviation?

Shares of Archer Aviation have broken a support level. This can be bearish and would suggest they trend lower.

Bill Ackman Has 70% Of His Portfolio Invested In These 5 Stocks: Here's What Q2 13F Filings Show

Discover how Bill Ackman invested ~70% of his $13.7M portfolio in 5 stocks like UBER & AMZN per Q2 2025 13F filings. Explore top holdings now!

TikTok + Touchdowns = Momentum

TikTok + Touchdowns = Momentum - Ad

NIL deals and social media clout are now driving merch sales into the billions. One Nasdaq disruptor is first to align with a football dynasty and a commerce giant.

California crew arrested for hundreds of Home Depot thefts worth $10M, police say

VENTURA COUNTY, Calif. (AP) — Southern California authorities say they uncovered a criminal ring that stole $10 million in merchandise from Home Depot over several years, including 600 thefts this year alone, which the company calls the largest organized retail theft in its history.

Mortgage Fraud Is Now A Trump-Era Flashpoint—Here's Everything You Need To Know

Given the recent high-profile cases, Benzinga decided to take a closer look at what mortgage fraud is and how it can be committed.

The New Way to Use AI in the Stock Market...

The New Way to Use AI in the Stock Market... - Ad

A Wall Street legend just helped train our own proprietary AI system in the stock market (a project that took dozens of technology and finance experts, including one PhD astrophysicist, and $4 million in total research costs). In a multi-year backtest, this breakthrough beat stocks, bonds, gold... even Warren Buffett.

The 4 rules for cash: How to manage your money the smart way

Let’s talk about cash.

Inside Warren Buffett's Decision to Keep Leading Berkshire Hathaway in His 90s

Warren Buffett's retirement decision has sparked debates about his reasons for working past the typical retirement age and his current choice to step aside.

Built for Gen Z. Backed by a Football Dynasty.

Built for Gen Z. Backed by a Football Dynasty. - Ad

This brand's not Nike-and that's the point. It's fast, tech-driven, and built for viral drops. Now, it has equity backing from one of college sports' most iconic names.

This Chinese $30K Tesla Model 3 Rival Secured 10,000 Orders In Seven Minutes

Xpeng's P7 sedan launched in China with over 10,000 orders in 7 mins. Rival Tesla also released new models for Chinese market.

Third Richest Woman In The World Eyes New York Giants Stake For Future Growth

One of the richest women in the world could have her eyes on more sports team ownership with a stake in the New York Giants.

October 16 Changes the Microchip Game - and Investing

October 16 Changes the Microchip Game - and Investing - Ad

George Gilder-dubbed "America's #1 Futurist"-says while everyone's chasing AI, the real opportunity is in a 4-nanometer tech millions of times more complex. It's not another chip - it replaces them. Now built in Arizona, Gilder says 3 companies tied to this "super-convergence" could soar.

Social Security whistleblower who claims DOGE mishandled Americans' sensitive data resigns from post

WASHINGTON (AP) — A Social Security official who has filed a whistleblower complaint alleging the Department of Government Efficiency officials Americans' sensitive information says he's resigning his post because of actions taken against him since making his complaint.

Marjorie Taylor Greene Put Money In BlackRock's Bitcoin ETF This Year — Here's How Her Returns Stack Up Against Others In Congress

Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) has added considerable Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) exposure to her investment portfolio in 2025, making strategic purchases into iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF (NASDAQ:IBIT).

"Tech Prophet" Who Predicted the iPhone Now Predicts...

"Tech Prophet" Who Predicted the iPhone Now Predicts... - Ad

George Gilder - who predicted the iPhone 17 years early and gave Reagan the first microchip - is making his boldest call yet. He says an American nanotech "super-convergence" could mint more millionaires than any event in recent memory. He's found 3 stocks set to benefit before Oct 16's bombshell.

Sikh truckers see spike in anti-immigrant vitriol after deadly Florida crash

Members of California’s Sikh trucking community say a deadly crash involving one of its own, which triggered heated national , has led to a spike in anti-Sikh rhetoric.

Cat in San Francisco euthanized after latest bird flu infection tied to raw pet food

Federal health officials are warning that certain lots of raw cat food may be contaminated after a pet cat in San Francisco that ate the food became infected with the virus and had to be euthanized.

The Tesla Shock Nobody Sees Coming

The Tesla Shock Nobody Sees Coming - Ad

While headlines scream "Tesla is doomed"...Jeff Brown has uncovered a revolutionary AI breakthrough buried inside Tesla's labs. One that is helping AI escape from our computer screens and manifest itself here in the real world all while creating a 25,000% growth market explosion starting as early as October 23rd.

Kevin O'Leary Recalls How Cutting Off His Son's Trust Fund Drove Him To Harvard: 'The Dead Bird Under The Nest Never Learns To Fly'

Kevin O'Leary revealed that cutting off his son's trust fund after high school and insisting on self-reliance motivated him to earn a spot at Harvard, emphasizing that entitlement ruins ambition.

Salmonella outbreak tied to recalled eggs has sickened 95 people since January

At least 95 people in more than a dozen states have been sickened since January in an outbreak of salmonella poisoning tied to recalled eggs, federal health officials

Analysts Project This Stock Could Jump to $14 a Share. You Can Still Invest for $3.50.

Analysts Project This Stock Could Jump to $14 a Share. You Can Still Invest for $3.50. - Ad

The AI company making heart disease easier to detect is offering investors $3.50 investment units that include one convertible preferred share and one warrant, providing investors with access to 2 common shares. Based on analyst 1- year projections, that amounts to a near-term 500% return potential.

Cathie Wood's Raises Wager On Ethereum-Hoarding Bitmine: Ark Buys Stock Of Tom Lee-Backed Company, Dumps Shares Of Sports Betting Giant

Ark Invest, led by Cathie Wood, executed significant trades on Wednesday, focusing on Bitmine Immersion Technologies Inc. (NYSE:BMNR) and DraftKings Inc. (NASDAQ:DKNG).

Bitcoin Will Correct Further In September, Analyst Maintains

Prominent crypto analyst Benjamin Cowen has emphasized his expectation of a September pullback for Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC), highlighting critical support levels to watch.

When Alabama Wins, This Nasdaq Brand Wins Too

When Alabama Wins, This Nasdaq Brand Wins Too - Ad

With equity in the brand and athletes pushing viral drops, the University of Alabama is betting on more than just football wins. This company built the tech-and got the team on board.

Rural Colorado mourns 6 who died from suspected gas exposure at dairy farm

Six workers who died in what authorities suspect was include a 50-year-old father and two sons, an incident that left rural Colorado communities in mourning.

OpenAI To Mass-Produce 1st Proprietary AI Chip With Broadcom, Secures $10 Billion Deal: Report

OpenAI is set to begin mass production of its first proprietary artificial intelligence chip next year through a partnership with Broadcom.

Is This Elon's Worst Nightmare?

Is This Elon's Worst Nightmare? - Ad

Elon's empire looks doomed - crashing sales, lost tax credits, and media backlash. But behind the scenes, Tesla is about to unleash a breakthrough Forbes calls a "multi-trillion-dollar opportunity." It's not the end - it's the start of a 25,000% AI comeback.

Takeaways from a hunt for 'secret' fresh water under the North Atlantic seabed

ABOARD LIFTBOAT ROBERT, North Atlantic (AP) — It turns out the Continental Shelf has been holding a secret from the ages. Beneath the sea floor off the U.S. northeast lies an enormous reserve of fresh water whose existence was long unknown, then was suspected and now is confirmed.

A preliminary report on Lisbon's streetcar tragedy is expected Friday

LISBON, Portugal (AP) — Details started to emerge about the people who were killed when a derailed, as the first investigative report examining what caused the popular Lisbon tourist attraction to crash was expected to be released Friday.

Could You Use Some Instant Cash Upfront?

Could You Use Some Instant Cash Upfront? - Ad

Millionaire trader Jeff Clark's #1 income strategy gives you the chance to collect instant cash payouts, as much as $100 to $1,000 upfront! The great part is you can collect these upfront cash payouts without owning a single stock.... Jeff's put all the details in a special briefing titled Infinite Income Manifesto.

Trump Warns Supreme Court Tariff Defeat Could Force US To 'Unwind' EU, Japan, South Korea Trade Deals — 'Our Country Is Going To Suffer So Greatly'

President Donald Trump warned against a Supreme Court ruling that could overturn his administration's tariff policies, saying that it could prove costly for the United States.

Moms' careers and personal time are hit hard by school drop-off demands, a poll finds

CHICAGO (AP) — When Elizabeth Rivera's phone would ring during the overnight shift, it was usually because again and one of her three kids needed a ride to school.

TikTok + Touchdowns = Momentum

TikTok + Touchdowns = Momentum - Ad

NIL deals and social media clout are now driving merch sales into the billions. One Nasdaq disruptor is first to align with a football dynasty and a commerce giant.

Trump Warns Foreign Chipmakers: Build In US Or 'We Will Be Putting A Very Substantial Tariff'

President Donald Trump on Thursday said his administration would soon impose tariffs on semiconductor imports from companies that have not committed to shifting production to the United States.

Robinhood Stock Surges Over 7% In Monday Pre-Market: What's Going On?

The stock of Robinhood Markets Inc. (NASDAQ: HOOD) surged 7.46% during the Monday pre-market trading session following Friday's news that it will be included in the S&P 500.

The New Way to Use AI in the Stock Market...

The New Way to Use AI in the Stock Market... - Ad

Salesforce, Rocket Lab, American Eagle, Gitlab And Figma: Why These 5 Stocks Are On Investors' Radars Today

CRM, RKLB, AEO, GTLB, FIG were among the stocks seen trending among investors on Wednesday, Sep. 3, 2025.

Bitcoin, Ethereum Brace For US Labor Data As Experts Warn Of Cross-Asset Volatility

Markets prepare for US labor data, a critical input for Fed policymakers. Figures will impact job market, inflation, and asset values globally.

Built for Gen Z. Backed by a Football Dynasty.

Built for Gen Z. Backed by a Football Dynasty. - Ad

This brand's not Nike-and that's the point. It's fast, tech-driven, and built for viral drops. Now, it has equity backing from one of college sports' most iconic names.

Homes Have Shrunk To The Smallest Average Size In 20 Years: Here's Why It Happened

Newly built homes in the U.S. are shrinking due to higher mortgage rates and affordability concerns. Buyers are adjusting expectations.

Trending Now