A Worldwide Gold Lockdown Is Now Underway

Gold is being stockpiled worldwide - banks, nations, billionaires. This isn't "just gold." A detailed plan could impact savings, investments and even mortgages. The free broadcast breaks it down and shows what to do before it's too late.

The surprising truth about dividend growth stocks

Dan Lefkovitz of Morningstar
September 16, 2025

Dividend growth investing isn't about maximizing current income, nor should it be confused with traditional growth investing. In fact, the Morningstar US Dividend Growth Index currently falls on the value side of the US stock market.

What is a dividend growth strategy? You might hear it pitched as a "quality"-focused investment approach, with "defensive" characteristics. Companies growing their payouts to shareholders are, in theory, financially secure. Their competitive positions are generally strong, even strengthening. By reputation, dividend growth stocks are less volatile than the broad market. These attributes have attracted billions in investor capital to funds with "dividend growth" in their names.

Yet, dividend growth stocks have underperformed the broad US equity market over the past decade. They have not lagged as far behind as the high-yield section of the market, but as a group they've failed to keep up. Let's look at what's behind their struggles.

Not Everything You Hear About Dividend Growth Stocks Is True

The Morningstar US Dividend Growth Index includes large-, mid-, and small-cap companies with a five-year history of increasing their cash payouts to shareholders. To be in the index, companies must display positive consensus earnings forecasts and must have a payout ratio under 75%. As of July 2025, 397 US companies met the index criteria.

The Morningstar US Dividend Growth Index and other dividend growth strategies score below the broad stock market on measures of corporate "quality" today. Dividend growth stocks currently lag the Morningstar US Market Index in profitability, financial strength, and returns on capital.

How can this be? Comparing the top 10 constituents of the Morningstar US Dividend Growth Index to those of the broad equity market as represented by the Morningstar US Market Index shows how concentrated the "broad" market has become in key technology and tech-adjacent companies--only a few of which are dividend growers.

The dividend growth index excludes phenomenally profitable stocks Nvidia NVDA, Amazon.com AMZN, Alphabet GOOGL, and Meta META. It includes Microsoft MSFT but at less than half the market weight. These lighter exposures help explain the "quality" gap.

They also help explain the underperformance. The biggest factor in the dividend growth index's lagging returns is its below-market weight to technology stocks. The second-biggest factor is excluding Alphabet and Meta.

How Has the Market's Dividend Growth Profile Changed?

Paying a dividend is a sign of maturation. When Meta and Alphabet initiated quarterly payouts to shareholders in 2024, it signaled they were entering a new life stage. Of the largest 10 stocks in today's market, only Amazon, Berkshire Hathaway BRK.B, and Tesla do not pay dividends.

Tech stocks are growing dividends more than in the past, with Microsoft as the index's top constituent. Ten years ago, tech stocks were roughly 12% of the dividend growth index; they now approach 20%. That's still well behind their share of the broad US stock market, which surpasses one third.

The financial services and healthcare sectors also have grown richer in dividend growth.

While industrials stocks still represent above-market exposure for the index, its share of the dividend growth universe has fallen over time (with the aerospace and defense industry an important exception). Consumer-related stocks also represent a smaller part of the universe than they once did, though Procter & Gamble PG and Home Depot HD remain top 10 constituents, and both Coke KO and Pepsi PEP make the top 20.

Sectors like utilities, energy, and basic materials also remain an important part of the dividend growth universe.

What Does This Mean for Dividend Growth Investors?

As a group, dividend growers currently lag the overall market on measures of "quality."

But that doesn't mean dividend growers aren't healthy businesses. What's more, they're trading at lower multiples than dividend-light growth stocks.

What's encouraging is that dividend growth has delivered a smoother ride than the broad market. Even if it doesn't always live up to its reputation for "quality," dividend growth investing can stake a valid claim at being a "defensive" strategy.

Companies growing their dividends remain a perfectly reasonable route to equity market participation, especially for risk-averse investors.

____

This article was provided to The Associated Press by Morningstar. For more personal finance content, go to https://www.morningstar.com/personal-finance

Dan Lefkovitz is a strategist for Morningstar Indexes.

Continue Reading...

Popular

Five 2026 vehicles you should absolutely wait for

Don’t buy that new car yet. If you can wait, you’ll have new 2026 model year options that aren’t out yet. Although some models barely change, others are completely redesigned and often get the latest features and improvements. Whether you’re interested in improved fuel economy, cutting-edge technology, or maybe just fresh and distinctive styling, there’s likely a car on the horizon that you’ll be interested in. To ensure you don’t miss out on the latest and greatest, the car experts at Edmunds highlight five vehicles you should consider waiting for.

Ex-Amazon driver sues civil rights agency for dropping her case following Trump's executive order

NEW YORK (AP) — A former Amazon delivery driver has filed a lawsuit accusing a federal civil right agency of abruptly and unlawfully abandoning her sex discrimination case and others like it following an executive order from President Donald Trump.

Gold's Rally Is Rewriting America's Financial Story - Ad

As inflation lingers and governments wobble, gold keeps breaking records - and U.S. supply is suddenly back in focus. One domestic gold play is riding this trend on multiple fronts.

Alibaba Unveils Next-Gen AI Models To Rival GPT-5

Alibaba Group is investing heavily in AI, launching new models and Plan C project. Analysts predict strong growth, driven by cloud and AI.

Trump Defends Missile Strike On 'Drug-Carrying' Submarine Amid Human Rights Outcry

Trump defends strike on drug sub, says it targeted fentanyl-laden vessel heading to US. Two survivors were rescued.

America's Next Gold Rush Is Gaining Speed - Ad

Record gold prices. Major partners in Nevada and Arizona. Billions in potential resources. The next chapter in America's gold story may already be unfolding - and one U.S. company is at the center of it.

Elizabeth Warren Warns One Of Trump's 'Billionaire Buddies' Wants To Buy Warner Bros, Warns Giant Company Could Control 'Everything' You Watch On TV

Sen. Elizabeth Warren warned that Trump-linked billionaire David Ellison's pursuit of Warner Bros. following his Paramount acquisition could create a media monopoly, raising concerns about concentration of power.

World Bank Partners With Private Equity In Global Critical Minerals Race

Private equity investors are investing $1B in critical minerals via Appian-IFC fund. This boosts supply chain security and local development.

Is This Elon's Worst Nightmare? - Ad

Elon's empire looks doomed - crashing sales, lost tax credits, and media backlash. But behind the scenes, Tesla is about to unleash a breakthrough Forbes calls a "multi-trillion-dollar opportunity." It's not the end - it's the start of a 25,000% AI comeback.

Dave Ramsey Doesn't Mess Around With Bitcoin Or Gold, Says 'I Have Three Investments' — Here's What They Are

Personal finance expert Dave Ramsey has long dismissed crypto, gold and single-stock investing, calling them risky distractions — but new research shows that his disciplined mutual fund approach may have cost him market-beating returns.

L3Harris Lands $2.26 Billion South Korea Air Defense Contract

L3Harris won a $2.26B deal to deliver modified Bombardier Global 6500 AEW&C aircraft to the South Korean Air Force.

The Tesla Shock Nobody Sees Coming - Ad

While headlines scream "Tesla is doomed"...Jeff Brown has uncovered a revolutionary AI breakthrough buried inside Tesla's labs. One that is helping AI escape from our computer screens and manifest itself here in the real world all while creating a 25,000% growth market explosion starting as early as October 23rd.

Gold Deals Pick Up As Metal Soars Past $4,200

Gold reaches new highs, expected to continue rallying into 2026. Multiple mergers and acquisitions in gold market.

Copper's Resurgence Prompts Domestic Asset Reactivation

The Fed's rate cut signals boosted copper prices by 1.8%, driven by demand from electrification and supply shortages.

Elon's New Device Could Launch Biggest IPO of the Decade - Ad

Elon Musk's new device is being called a "game-changer"-and even the White House is using this tech. Jeff Brown says it could launch Musk's next trillion-dollar company and make early investors rich. You can claim a stake now for as little as $500.

Elizabeth Warren Blasts Amazon For Internet Meltdown, Says 'If A Company Can Break The Entire Internet, They Are Too Big'

Sen. Elizabeth Warren renewed her call to break up Big Tech after a massive Amazon Web Services outage disrupted major global platforms, saying, "If a company can break the entire internet, they are too big."

Tim Cook To Depart, Steve Jobs' Lesson For Guy Kawasaki And More: This Week In Appleverse

From executive shake-ups at Apple to TSMC's revenue surge and Goldman's take on the AI boom, here are the top Apple stories.

The 7 Red Flags Wall Street Won't Talk About - Ad

All 7 historic crash signals are flashing red. Once the public notices, it's too late. Our free Bellwether Signal explains how to protect wealth - and why gold and silver have been the refuge in every crisis. Don't let your retirement go over a cliff.

November 18: D-Day For The Dollar - Ad

A quiet shift in U.S. law has just authorized private companies to mint a new form of government-authorized money called the "Dollar 2.0"... and the next major mint hits on November 18. Investors who make the right moves before then could make up to 40X by 2032...

Kevin O'Leary Tells Trump His 'No. 1 Job' Is To Protect The American Dream, Not Pick Sectors In The Economy

Kevin O'Leary urged President Donald Trump to prioritize protecting the American dream and preserving capitalism over picking economic winners, warning that government overreach and bad policy threaten the nation's entrepreneurial spirit amid growing pessimism about upward mobility.

MP Materials Tops List For Rare Earth Exposure, Says Analyst

Rare earth stocks are gaining attention as demand for magnets in EVs, robotics, and advanced air mobility is set to double by 2035.

Elon's $25 Trillion Confession - Ad

Elon Musk: "Tesla will become a $25 trillion company." That would make Tesla 8x bigger than Apple today. How is that possible? He admits it's all thanks to this one AI breakthrough that will take AI out of our computer screens and manifest a 250x boom here in the real world.

What's Going On With Galaxy Digital Stock Monday?

Galaxy is in the spotlight Monday ahead of third quarter earnings on Tuesday before the market opens.

Cathie Wood Dumps $3.7 Million Of Palantir Stock Despite AI Boom — Here's What She's Buying Instead

Ark Invest boosted positions in Qualcomm and BYD, while trimming Palantir and Shopify. Ark also acquired shares of China's BYD despite recent recall.

On October 16, a powerful new law signed by President Trump will trigger a radical shift in America's money system... - Ad

When a small group of private companies - not the Fed - will perform a major mint of a new kind of money. And those who act before this new system fully kicks in could see gains as high as 40X by 2032. But those who fail to prepare will be blindsided by this sea change to the U.S. dollar.

Ethereum Crashes To $4,100 As Senate Democrats Take Aim At DeFi

Ethereum (CRYPTO: ETH) is trading near $4,100 on Friday, after a sharp selloff that followed its rejection from $4,700 and renewed fears of U.S.

A Worldwide Gold Lockdown Is Now Underway - Ad

Gold is being stockpiled worldwide - banks, nations, billionaires. This isn't "just gold." A detailed plan could impact savings, investments and even mortgages. The free broadcast breaks it down and shows what to do before it's too late.

Xi Jinping Faces 'Unprecedented' Turmoil Within Communist Party, Says Leading China Expert As Trump Ramps Up Tariffs

As U.S.-China trade tensions continue to escalate amid President Donald Trump's threat to add another 100% tariff on imports from the nation starting Nov. 1, Chinese President Xi Jinping is facing a rare challenge at home, according to political scientist Gordon Chang.

Gold's Rally Is Rewriting America's Financial Story - Ad

As inflation lingers and governments wobble, gold keeps breaking records - and U.S. supply is suddenly back in focus. One domestic gold play is riding this trend on multiple fronts.

Polymarket Says $95,000 Is More Likely Than $130,000 — But This Bitcoin Trendline Disagrees

Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) is stuck near $111,000 as prediction markets see a slide toward $95,000 as possible, even while technical charts still flash room for a rebound toward $130,000.

Why Is BTQ Technologies Stock Up Today?

Shares of BTQ Technologies Corp. (NASDAQ:BTQ) are rising Thursday after the company announced that it reached a significant technological milestone.

America's Next Gold Rush Is Gaining Speed - Ad

Record gold prices. Major partners in Nevada and Arizona. Billions in potential resources. The next chapter in America's gold story may already be unfolding - and one U.S. company is at the center of it.

Dogecoin's $0.21 Problem: Why This Analyst Says Keep It On Your Radar

On Monday, social media influencer Ali Martinez, known popularly on X as Ali, drew the attention of the crypto community to an important resistance level for Dogecoin (CRYPTO: DOGE).

OpenAI's ChatGPT To Allow Erotica For Adults: Not 'Moral Police Of The World,' Sam Altman Says

OpenAI will begin allowing erotica and adult-themed content on ChatGPT, marking a major shift in the company's content policy.

Is This Elon's Worst Nightmare? - Ad

Elon's empire looks doomed - crashing sales, lost tax credits, and media backlash. But behind the scenes, Tesla is about to unleash a breakthrough Forbes calls a "multi-trillion-dollar opportunity." It's not the end - it's the start of a 25,000% AI comeback.

Faulty engineering led to implosion of Titan submersible headed to Titanic wreckage, NTSB finds

PORTLAND, Maine (AP) — Faulty engineering led to the implosion of an experimental submersible that killed five people on the way to the wreck of the , the National Transportation Safety Board concluded in a report Wednesday.

Trending Now

Information, charts or examples are for illustration and educational purposes only and not for individualized investment management This message contains commercial elements, such as advertising. We only send these offers to those who have opted in to our newsletter. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For these reasons we strongly suggest trading in a DEMO/Simulated account. The information provided by us is for educational and informational purposes only. We make no representations or warranties concerning the products, practices or procedures of any company or entity mentioned or recommended and have not determined if the statements and opinions of the advertiser are accurate, correct or truthful. If you use, act upon or make decisions in reliance on information contained or any external source linked within it, you do so at your own peril and agree to hold us, our officers, directors, shareholders, affiliates and agents without fault.

Copyright activatrade.ca
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service