Alex's Mystery Guest Makes Shocking Trump Revelation

Over the next 4 years, Trump is about to create something extraordinary. A real chance for everyday Americans to build serious wealth... wealth that would dwarf what we saw in his first term. We're talking about a potential economic transformation that could mint 20 million new millionaires. Put everything else aside and watch this special event right now.

He is credited with one of history's most indelible photos. A new documentary questions who took it

DAVID BAUDER
January 16, 2025

It is one of the 20th century's most memorable images: a naked girl, screaming, running from a napalm bombing during the Vietnam War. More than a half-century later, a new documentary is calling into question who took it -- and the retired Associated Press photographer long credited for the photo insists it was his, while his longtime employer says it has no evidence of anyone else being behind the camera.

The film about the Pulitzer Prize-winning picture, "The Stringer," is scheduled to debut next week at the Sundance Film Festival. Both photographer Nick Ut and his longtime employer are contesting it vigorously, and Ut's lawyer is seeking to block the premiere, threatening a defamation lawsuit. The AP, which conducted its own investigation over six months, concluded it has "no reason to believe anyone other than Ut took the photo."

The picture of Kim Phuc running down a road in the village of Trang Bang, crying and naked because she had taken off clothes burning from napalm, instantly became symbolic of the horrors of the Vietnam War.

Taken on June 8, 1972, the photo is credited to Ut, then a 21-year-old staffer in AP's Saigon bureau. He was awarded the Pulitzer a year later. Now 73, he moved to California after the war and worked for the AP for 40 years until retiring in 2017.

The film's allegations open an unexpected new chapter for an image that, within hours of it being taken, was beamed around the planet and became one of the most indelible photographs of both the Vietnam War and the turbulent century that produced it. Whatever the truth, the film's investigations apparently relate only to the identity of the photographer and not the image's overall authenticity.

The dispute puts the filmmakers, who call the episode "a scandal behind the making of one of the most-recognized photographs of the 20th century," at odds with Ut, whose work that day defined his career. It also puts them at cross purposes with the AP, a global news organization for whom accuracy is a foundational part of the business model.

How did the questioning of the photo begin?

It's difficult, so many years later, to overestimate the wallop that this particular image packed. Ron Burnett, an expert on images and former president of the Emily Carr University of Art and Design, called it "earth-shattering."

"It changed the way photos have always been thought about and broke the rules for how much violence you can show to the public," Burnett said.

The photo sat unchallenged for much of its 53-year existence. All these years later, a counter-narrative has emerged that it was instead taken by another person, someone who worked for NBC News at the time and also lives now in California. The person allegedly had his film delivered his film to the AP's office as a "stringer," a non-staff member who provides material to a news organization.

The husband-and-wife team of Gary Knight, founder of the VII Foundation, and producer Fiona Turner are behind the film. On his website, Knight described "The Stringer" as "a story that many in our profession did not want told, and some of them continue to go to great lengths to make sure isn't told."

"The film grapples with questions of authorship, racial injustice and journalistic ethics while shining a light on the fundamental yet often unrecognized contributions of local freelancers who provide the information we need to understand how events worldwide impact us all," Knight wrote.

Knight did not return a message seeking comment from the AP on Thursday. A representative from Sundance also did not return a message about a cease-and-desist letter from Ut's lawyer, James Hornstein, trying to stop the film's airing. Hornstein would not make Ut available for an interview, saying he anticipated future litigation.

Knight and Turner met with AP in London last June about the allegations. According to the AP, filmmakers requested the news organization sign a non-disclosure agreement before they provided their evidence. AP declined.

That hampered the AP's own investigation, along with the passage of time. Horst Faas, chief of photos for AP in Saigon in 1972, and Yuichi "Jackson" Ishizaki, who developed Ut's film, are both dead. Many of the Saigon bureau's records were lost when communists took over the city, including any dealings with "the stringer." Negatives of photos used back then are preserved in AP's corporate archives in New York, but they provided no insight for the investigation.

Still, the AP decided to release its own findings before seeing "The Stringer" and the details of the claim that it is making. "AP stands prepared to review any evidence and take whatever remedial action might be needed if their thesis is proved true," the news organization said.

Some who were there are sure about what happened

The AP said it spoke to seven surviving people who were in Trang Bang or AP's Saigon bureau that day, and all maintain they have no reason to doubt their own conclusions that Ut had taken the photo.

One was Fox Butterfield, a renowned longtime New York Times reporter, who also said that he was contacted by Turner for the documentary. "I told them what my memory was and they didn't like it, but they just went ahead anyway," Butterfield told AP.

Another was photographer David Burnett, who said he witnessed Ut and Alexander Shimkin, a freelance photographer working primarily for Newsweek, taking photos as Kim Phuc and other children emerged from smoke following an attack. Shimkin was killed in Vietnam a month later, according to the investigation.

A key source for the story in "The Stringer" is Carl Robinson, then a photo editor for the AP in Saigon, who was initially overruled in his judgment not to use the picture. AP reached out to Robinson as part of its probe, but he said he had signed an NDA with Knight and the VII Foundation. Knight followed up, saying Robinson would only speak off the record, which the AP concluded would have prevented the news organization from setting the record straight.

Robinson did not immediately reply to an email seeking comment on Thursday.

On duty that day in Saigon, Robinson had concluded that Ut's picture could not be used because it would have violated standards prohibiting nudity. But Faas overruled him, and senior AP editors in New York decided to run the picture for what it conveyed about war.

The AP questioned Robinson's long silence in contradicting Ut's photo credit, and showed a photo from its archives of Robinson with champagne toasting Ut's Pulitzer Prize. In a 2005 interview with corporate archives, Robinson said he thought AP "created a monster" when it distributed the photo because much of the world's sympathies were focused on one victim, instead of war victims more broadly.

Former AP correspondent Peter Arnett, who believes Ut made the image, said Robinson wrote to him after Faas' death in 2012 to make the allegation that Ut had not taken it; he said he did not want to do it while Faas was still alive. According to the AP investigation, Arnett said Robinson told him that Ut had "gone all Hollywood" and he didn't like it.

Hornstein characterized Robinson, who was dismissed by AP in 1978, as "a guy with a 50-year vendetta against the AP." He also questioned the long silence by the man supposedly identified in the documentary as the person who really took the photo.

The lawyer also produced a statement from Kim Phuc, who said that while she has no memory of that day, her uncle has repeatedly told her that Ut took the picture and that she had no reason to doubt him. Ut also took her to the nearest hospital after the photo was taken, she wrote.

___

David Bauder writes about media for the AP. Follow him at http://x.com/dbauder and https://bsky.app/profile/dbauder.bsky.social

Continue Reading...

Popular

NATO is deploying eyes in the sky and on the Baltic Sea to protect vital cables. Here's why and how

ABOARD A FRENCH NAVY FLIGHT OVER THE BALTIC SEA (AP) — With , the French Navy surveillance plane scouring zoomed in on a cargo ship plowing the waters below — closer, closer and closer still until the camera operator could make out details on the vessel's front deck and smoke pouring from its chimney.

A food bank netted a huge haul of 13,000 fresh salmon. The catch? The fish were still alive

AUBURN, N.Y. (AP) — A New York food bank was offered a huge donation of fresh fish this month — but it came with a catch.

The $20 Stock Powering NVIDIA, TESLA, and Microsoft - Ad

The biggest AI firms in the world... All rely on this single company. And right now, you can get in for only $20 - but not for long.

Trump's Commerce Secretary nominee, Howard Lutnick, vows to sell his business interests in 90 days

WASHINGTON (AP) — Billionaire financier Howard Lutnick, President Donald Trump's choice to lead the Commerce Department, said Wednesday that he would sell all of his business holdings within 90 days.

Hawaii wildfire victims spared from testifying after last-minute deal over $4B settlement

HONOLULU (AP) — Lawyers representing victims of a deadly Hawaii wildfire reached a last-minute deal averting a trial Wednesday to determine how to split a .

22X Better Than Bitcoin... Without Crypto - Ad

For every $1,000 made in Bitcoin... you could have made as much as $22,000 with this strategy. legendary former hedge fund manager Larry Benedict calls it "Bitcoin Skimming." And get this... it's CRUSHING Bitcoin's returns. If you want to get in on the ground floor then watch this free interview NOW.

South Carolina treasurer calls questions of his role in $1.8 billion accounting error a witch hunt

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — South Carolina Treasurer Curtis Loftis said Wednesday that calls for him to resign over that left the state trying to figure out what happened to a $1.8 billion fund amounted to a witch hunt.

Did DeepSeek copy ChatGPT? Trump adviser thinks so

Did the upstart copy ChatGPT to make the artificial intelligence technology that this week?

Ex CIA Predicts 40% "Double Crash" -- April 11 - Ad

I strongly advise taking action ahead of this NEW kind of economic crash... What makes this new crash so uniquely dangerous is that it could erase bank accounts.... My best followers are already following the steps laid out in this video. Prepare now, or suffer when the market implodes by 40% in a single day as soon as April 11. You've been warned.

Edmunds' hybrid SUV test: 2025 Hyundai Tucson Hybrid vs 2025 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid

Hybrids are hot right now, and you have lots of choices if you’re considering a hybrid SUV. For years, the Toyota RAV4 Hybrid has been the go-to model for hybrid SUV shoppers.

Magnificent 7 Earnings Ahead: 3 ETFs To Ride The Wave

Earnings season in full swing, attention on tech giants known as Magnificent 7: 3 ETFs to consider.

The DOGE Agenda (Eight Stocks to Buy) - Ad

Every investor in America is trying to figure out what Musk will do in Washington, D.C. in the coming weeks.

Top-Secret Military Base in New Mexico Desert - Ad

Out in the New Mexico desert sits a top secret government facility... The scientists here are studying a new technology that will change the way wars are fought... Once you see this thing for yourself -- you'll know in your heart it could be coming for all of us. That's why I've taken steps to help protect myself and my family from what could be unleashed as early as April 11.

Donald and Melania Trump Memecoins Outgain Bitcoin, Ethereum Amid Market Lull -- Analyst Says TRUMP Bottomed Out At $25

President Donald Trump‘s meme coin outperformed the broader cryptocurrency market with a double-digit surge on Monday. What happened: The Official Trump (TRUMP) token surged over 10% in the last 24 hours, reaching a market valuation of $5.92 billion and a fully diluted value of $29.62 billion. 

Gary Black Calls Tesla's Austin Robotaxi Launch By June 'Most Bullish' Takeaway, But Wants Answers On Auto Margins And Next-Gen EV

Tesla Inc. bull Gary Black highlighted the company's planned autonomous ride-hailing service in Austin as a significant development while expressing concerns about automotive margins and the forthcoming affordable electric vehicle's design.

Crypto Stocks Are Heating Up - Ad

At the center of this transformation is a game-changing platform that's experiencing explosive growth with $41 million in revenue in just nine months. The stock has doubled in the last 45 days, but this is only the beginning.

Europe's economy showed zero growth at end of 2024 as Germany, eurozone's biggest economy, struggled

FRANKFURT, Germany (AP) — Europe’s economy stagnated at the end of last year as its former growth engine, Germany, finished a second straight year of shrinking output, officials said Thursday.

Elon Musk's Critical Metals Warning: What Investors Need to Know - Ad

Elon Musk has repeatedly warned about the looming critical metals crisis, calling materials like nickel, copper, and PGMs essential to Tesla's future. One Canadian discovery in Quebec is drawing comparisons to Russia's Norilsk Mine and has the potential to reshape global supply chains. With heavyweight backers and a fully funded exploration plan, this opportunity demands attention.

Hong Kong's snake soup is slithering away but still simmers in a decades-old kitchen

HONG KONG (AP) — As Hong Kong prepares to welcome the Year of the Snake on Wednesday, Chau Ka-ling displays a moving serpent with practiced ease, holding it like a pet in her decades-old restaurant in the city.

Mark Zuckerberg Says China's DeepSeek Did Some Novel Things 'We're Still Digesting,' But Meta May Keep Pouring Billions Into AI Infrastructure Anyway

Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg acknowledged that China's DeepSeek made novel advancements that Meta is still evaluating but emphasized that the company will continue investing billions in AI infrastructure, seeing it as a long-term strategic advantage.

What Bill O'Reilly Said Floored Me - Ad

Bill O'Reilly has trusted one expert for investment advice for over 20 years... Alexander Green. Now, Alex is revealing Trump's impact on YOUR Money, like how AI technology could amplify Trump's policies and details on 3 stocks that could rise 20-fold by 2029.

Senate confirms Zeldin to lead Environmental Protection Agency as Trump vows to cut climate rules

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Republican-controlled Senate on Wednesday confirmed Lee Zeldin to lead the Environmental Protection Agency, a key role to help President Donald Trump fulfill his pledge to roll back major environmental regulations, including those aimed at slowing climate change and encouraging use of electric vehicles.

Undervalued Robotics Stock Alert - Ad

Why is an AI robotics company with $3.2M in revenue valued at just $50M while competitors with less revenue sit at $448M?

MrBeast And Group Of Investors, Including Roblox CEO, Lock In Over $20 Billion For TikTok Takeover

A group of American investors, including YouTube star MrBeast and Roblox CEO David Baszucki, has secured over $20 billion for a potential TikTok takeover, but ByteDance has yet to respond to their bid.

Bill Ackman Questions Whether DeepSeek AI's Hedge Fund Affiliate Profited From Nvidia's Sell-Off: 'A Fortune Could Have Been Made'

Billionaire investor Bill Ackman questioned whether DeepSeek's hedge fund affiliate potentially profited from Monday's tech stock rout, which saw Nvidia Corp. shares plunge 17% following the Chinese artificial intelligence startup's emergence as a potential disruptor.

Major Gold Tipping Point Predicted - Ad

Gold has already taken Wall Street by surprise... During Trump's first term, it shot up by 53%. And it has crushed the market nearly 3-to-1 since the start of the 21st century.But that's just a drop in the bucket compared to what one expert expects gold to do next... $22,227 an ounce. Why such a huge jump? Because of the three simple charts shown right here.

Spain's leader wants the EU to 'make social media great again.' Here's how

DAVOS, Switzerland (AP) — Spanish Prime Minister is launching a crusade against what he sees as the downsides of .

Who can share seeds? As climate change and counterfeits hurt Kenyan farmers, it's a growing question

KIKUYU, Kenya (AP) — Tucked away in a lush, forested area of central Kenya's Kikuyu town, the National Seed Bank stands as a crucial safeguard for the future of the country's agriculture. Inside two chilly rooms of a government building, more than 50,000 seed varieties are cataloged and stored.

Crypto Stocks Surge Amid Market Boom - Ad

Crypto stocks are on fire as Bitcoin hits all-time highs. One under-the-radar company is leading the charge, managing $2.1 billion in client assets and seeing record trading volumes. With crypto adoption skyrocketing, this could be a game-changing opportunity.

Robert Kiyosaki Predicts Yet Another Stock Market Crash, Pitches Bitcoin Investments -- Here's What The 'Rich Dad Poor Dad' Author Said

Renowned investor and author Robert Kiyosaki on Monday predicted a major stock market crash in February and advised investors to focus on Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC), gold, and silver.

Starbucks reports better-than-expected quarterly sales as turnaround efforts begin

on Tuesday reported better-than-expected sales in its fiscal first quarter as some of its turnaround efforts start to take hold.

JFK, 9/11... And Now This? - Ad

Jim Rickards says we'll never forget April 11, 2025. Jim outlines a crash so terrible it may even have the power to wipe out the checking and savings accounts at your bank... Along with 40% of the market. Jim is one of America's best geopolitical analysts... All you need to know is in a quick summary of his latest book.

3 coup-hit West African nations formally leave ECOWAS in an unprecedented disintegration

ABUJA, Nigeria (AP) — The of Niger, Mali and Burkina Faso have formally withdrawn from the regional bloc known as ECOWAS, the body said Wednesday, the culmination of a yearlong process during which the group tried to avert its unprecedented disintegration.

Urgent Bitcoin Alert for Right Now - Ad

"Bitcoin Skimming" could help you multiply Bitcoin gains by up to 22x. Former billion-dollar hedge fund manager Larry Benedict reveals his strategy that everyone needs to understand. And the wild thing? You don't even need to buy, sell, or own Bitcoin to do this.

AI-assisted works can get copyright with enough human creativity, says US copyright office

Artists can copyright works they made with the help of artificial intelligence, according to a new report by the U.S. Copyright Office that could help clear the way for the use of AI tools in Hollywood, the music industry and other creative fields.

Trending Now

Information, charts or examples are for illustration and educational purposes only and not for individualized investment management This message contains commercial elements, such as advertising. We only send these offers to those who have opted in to our newsletter. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For these reasons we strongly suggest trading in a DEMO/Simulated account. The information provided by us is for educational and informational purposes only. We make no representations or warranties concerning the products, practices or procedures of any company or entity mentioned or recommended and have not determined if the statements and opinions of the advertiser are accurate, correct or truthful. If you use, act upon or make decisions in reliance on information contained or any external source linked within it, you do so at your own peril and agree to hold us, our officers, directors, shareholders, affiliates and agents without fault.

Copyright activatrade.ca
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service